TPU vs TPE Adhesion Properties Across Different Substrates
Peel strength, lap shear, and failure mode are the three measurements that characterize elastomer-to-substrate adhesion in production settings. Each tells a different part of the story — peel strength quantifies force, failure mode reveals whether the bond or the material is the weak link, and lap shear measures resistance to the loading direction most common in assembled products. Understanding how TPU and TPE perform across these three dimensions on different substrates, and why the values vary, gives engineers a more complete picture than data sheet rankings alone provide. Peel Strength: What the Numbers Represent Peel strength for overmolded elastomers is typically measured by the 90-degree peel test (ASTM D1876 or ISO 11339), which measures the force per unit width required to peel the elastomer from the substrate at a 90-degree angle. Values are reported in N/mm or lb/in. Peel strength values for elastomers on engineering substrates range widely — from below 1 N/mm for poorly bonded combinations to above 8–10 N/mm for well-bonded cohesive-failure systems. But the absolute value is less important than the failure mode it accompanies. Cohesive failure (elastomer tears) indicates that the bond exceeded the elastomer's tensile strength. The bond strength is bounded below by the measured peel force and is actually higher — the interface did not fail, the material did. This is the acceptance criterion for structural overmolding. Adhesive failure (clean separation at the interface, substrate surface remains intact) indicates that the bond strength is lower than the elastomer's cohesive strength. The measured peel force is an accurate upper bound on the bond strength. Parts that fail adhesively in peel testing are at risk for progressive delamination in service under real load conditions. TPU Adhesion Values Across Substrates TPU adhesion on polar engineering substrates under optimized production conditions: TPU on ABS: Cohesive failure at 4–9 N/mm peel depending on Shore hardness (softer grades produce higher peel strength by presenting more contact area per unit width). Lap shear typically 8–15 MPa on clean ABS surfaces. TPU on PC: Cohesive failure at 3–8 N/mm peel on properly dried, stress-relieved PC with CSC-screened TPU formulation. Softer grades again produce higher peel values. TPU on PA6/PA66: Cohesive failure at 3–7 N/mm peel on dry-as-molded, optimally processed substrates. Moisture-conditioned PA substrates produce lower values — often 1.5–4 N/mm — demonstrating the peel strength sensitivity to substrate moisture content. TPU on PA12: Adhesive failure without silane primer at typically 0.5–2 N/mm. With silane primer: cohesive failure at 2–4 N/mm, demonstrating the primer's substantial impact on PA12 bond strength. TPU on PP (plasma treated): Adhesive failure at 1–3 N/mm even with treatment. Not cohesive failure territory for structural applications. TPE Adhesion Values Across Substrates SEBS on ABS: Cohesive failure at 3–8 N/mm under controlled process (mold temperature >60°C). Lower than high-end TPU but adequate for most consumer product grip and soft-touch applications. Below 60°C mold temperature: adhesive failure at 1–3 N/mm — demonstrating the sensitivity of SEBS adhesion to process parameters. COPE on PC: Cohesive failure at 3–7 N/mm with mold temperature…