Threadlockers vs. Retaining Compounds: A Manufacturer’s Guide
Threadlockers and retaining compounds are both anaerobic adhesives, and they share a curing mechanism, but they are formulated for different jobs. Knowing which one a joint needs is the first step toward a reliable, cost-effective assembly. A Shared Curing Principle Both products stay liquid in air and cure rapidly only when confined between close-fitting metal surfaces without oxygen, with metal ions acting as the catalyst. That is why both are effective at preventing loosening, sealing against leaks, and resisting corrosion in confined metal-to-metal joints. Their formulations and intended applications diverge from there. Threadlockers: Securing Threaded Fasteners Threadlockers are anaerobic adhesives for threaded assemblies, meaning nuts, bolts, screws, and studs. Their job is to keep fasteners from loosening under vibration, thermal cycling, or shock. Applied to the threads, the liquid flows into the microscopic gaps between mating threads. Once assembled, the exclusion of air triggers the cure, forming a solid bond that locks the threads, removes radial play, and holds clamp load. Key points: Target: threaded fasteners. Gap: the small, consistent clearance of a thread fit, typically up to about 0.15 mm. Viscosity: low to medium, to flow into fine threads. Strength grades: low strength for small fasteners needing frequent removal; medium strength as the general-purpose choice, removable with hand tools; high strength for permanent joints that come apart only with heat and force; wicking grade with very low viscosity to penetrate pre-assembled fasteners. Benefits: resists vibrational loosening, seals threads against leaks and corrosion, and can replace lock washers and cotter pins, simplifying inventory. Retaining Compounds: Strengthening Cylindrical Fits Retaining compounds are anaerobic adhesives for non-threaded cylindrical assemblies: bearings, bushings, gears, pulleys, and shafts fitted into housings or onto shafts. They augment or replace press and shrink fits by bonding across the entire mating surface. Applied to the cylindrical surfaces, the compound fills the microscopic voids that remain even in a precise fit. On assembly, air exclusion cures it, turning the fit into a unitized joint with full surface contact. Key points: Target: cylindrical, non-threaded assemblies. Gap: larger and more variable than threadlockers, typically up to 0.25 mm, and up to 0.5 mm for some grades. Viscosity: generally higher, to bridge larger clearances and resist run-out. Strength: higher shear strength than threadlockers, because the bond area is larger and must transmit significant loads. Benefits: increases the strength of press and slip fits, eliminates fretting corrosion from micro-movement, seals against contaminants, and allows looser machining tolerances, which can reduce cost. Choosing between the two is usually clear once you identify whether you are securing a bolt or strengthening a cylindrical joint. Email Us to review your assemblies with Incure's technical team. Key Distinctions at a Glance Feature Threadlocker Retaining Compound Primary application Threaded fasteners Cylindrical non-threaded parts Function Prevent loosening, seal threads Strengthen cylindrical fits, prevent fretting Gap filling Smaller, consistent, up to about 0.15 mm Larger, variable, up to about 0.5 mm Strength focus Breakaway and prevailing torque Shear strength, axial and radial load Viscosity Lower to medium Often higher Disassembly…