Stress does not remain constant in an adhesive bond. Even without any change in applied load, the stress in an adhesive joint decreases over time at elevated temperature as the polymer network slowly reorganizes to accommodate the imposed strain. This process — stress relaxation — has consequences that range from beneficial (reducing residual stress that would otherwise drive failure) to problematic (losing the preload that keeps a sealed joint closed, allowing components to shift in precision assemblies, or allowing previously constrained structures to warp when load-bearing stress relaxes unevenly).

What Thermal Relaxation Is

Stress relaxation is the decrease in stress over time when an adhesive is held at constant deformation. It is distinct from creep, which is the increase in strain over time under constant load. Both are manifestations of the same underlying viscoelastic behavior of polymer materials, and in practice both occur simultaneously in bonded joints — but stress relaxation is the relevant mode when the joint is geometrically constrained by the substrates.

At room temperature, stress relaxation in well-cured thermoset adhesives is extremely slow and for most practical purposes negligible over typical service periods. As temperature rises, relaxation rate increases sharply, roughly doubling for every 10–15°C rise for many adhesive systems. Near the glass transition temperature, relaxation is rapid and nearly complete within minutes to hours. Above the Tg, the adhesive behaves as a viscoelastic fluid that relaxes essentially all stress given enough time.

In bonded assemblies, thermal relaxation occurs whenever the adhesive is at elevated temperature, and the relaxed stress state is the baseline from which subsequent cooling and thermomechanical loading must be calculated.

Sources of Stress That Undergo Thermal Relaxation

Cure Residual Stress

When an adhesive cures at elevated temperature and the assembly cools, residual stress builds in the bond line from CTE mismatch between adhesive and substrate. This residual stress is the largest pre-existing stress in most bonded assemblies, and it exists before any service loading is applied.

If the assembly is subsequently returned to a temperature near the cure temperature — during a rework step, a post-cure operation, or a hot service environment — the residual stress partially or fully relaxes. When the assembly cools again, new residual stress builds from the new temperature baseline. If the relaxation was complete, the new residual stress magnitude equals what would have been generated from a fresh cure at the exposure temperature; if partial, the residual stress is some intermediate value.

Mechanically Induced Stress from Fit-Up

During assembly, components are often forced into alignment before the adhesive cures or while the adhesive is still at elevated temperature. The mechanical force required to hold misaligned parts in their designed positions is transmitted to the adhesive as pre-load stress. If the adhesive is held at elevated temperature long enough to relax this stress, the parts may shift when the applied force is released — even if the adhesive has cured — because the stress that was maintaining alignment has been removed.

CTE Mismatch Thermal Stress

During service at elevated temperature, CTE mismatch stress builds in the adhesive bond as the assembly heats. If the elevated temperature is sustained, stress relaxation progressively reduces this thermally induced stress. When the assembly cools, the relaxed stress state means the adhesive does not return to its original dimensions. Instead, it cools from a stress-free configuration at the elevated temperature, building new CTE mismatch stress (in the direction opposite to heating) as it cools. The net result after a complete heat-and-cool cycle that includes stress relaxation is a different residual stress state than before the cycle — and this change accumulates over multiple cycles.

Email Us to discuss stress relaxation characterization and its effects on your bonded assembly’s dimensional stability.

Consequences of Thermal Relaxation in Service

Loss of Preload in Seals and Clamped Joints

Adhesive-sealed joints that rely on compressive preload to maintain sealing contact — gasketed joints, press-fit bonds, compression-loaded assemblies — lose sealing force as the adhesive relaxes at elevated temperature. If the relaxation removes the preload entirely, the joint opens and leaks. This failure mode is particularly important for seals in chemical processing, hydraulic, and pneumatic systems that operate at elevated temperature.

The seal design must account for the amount of preload that will be lost to relaxation over the operating life, and the initial preload must be set high enough to maintain adequate sealing force throughout the service period.

Dimensional Drift in Precision Assemblies

In precision instruments, optical systems, and electronic assemblies where component alignment is critical, stress relaxation can allow slow positional drift. A component bonded in a precise location with a stressed adhesive bond will shift as the stress relaxes, moving to a position dictated by the relaxed strain state. For assemblies that operate at elevated temperature and require micrometer-level alignment stability, stress relaxation is a fundamental limit on achievable stability.

This problem is managed by curing the adhesive at or above the service temperature, allowing full relaxation during cure, and then cooling the assembly to its service temperature from a stress-free hot state. The residual stress after this process is set only by the CTE mismatch on cooling, not by any additional mechanically imposed stress.

Warping from Differential Relaxation

If different regions of a bonded assembly relax at different rates — because they are at different temperatures, have different adhesive thicknesses, or contain adhesive in different states of cure — the differential relaxation produces bowing and warping. The regions that relax most completely achieve different stress states than those that relax least, and the resulting stress gradient drives curvature.

This differential relaxation warping is a common problem in large composite-metal bonded panels where one side runs hotter than the other, causing one adhesive layer to relax more than the other and producing a progressive bowing that continues as long as the temperature differential is maintained.

Stress Redistribution and Localized Failure

Stress relaxation does not remove stress from a structure — it redistributes it. When the adhesive relaxes, the load it was carrying is transferred to adjacent materials. In assemblies with mixed adhesive types, or adhesive joints adjacent to mechanical fasteners, selective relaxation of the more viscoelastic component transfers load to the stiffer component. This load redistribution can overload the fastener, adjacent bond, or substrate if the total load remains the same but the distribution changes significantly.

Characterizing Stress Relaxation in Adhesive Systems

Stress Relaxation Testing

Standard stress relaxation tests apply a defined displacement to an adhesive specimen and measure the force decay over time at constant temperature. Repeating this at multiple temperatures provides the time-temperature dependence of relaxation, which is described by the relaxation modulus E(t):

E(t) = σ(t) / ε₀

Where σ(t) is the stress at time t and ε₀ is the constant applied strain.

The relaxation modulus decreases from the instantaneous modulus at t=0 to the equilibrium modulus (ideally zero for a crosslinked system, in practice a small finite value from the crosslink network’s entropic spring contribution) over a characteristic relaxation time that is highly temperature-dependent.

Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA)

DMA provides the frequency-dependent storage modulus E'(ω) and loss modulus E”(ω) across a temperature range. Through time-temperature superposition, this data can be shifted to construct master curves that predict relaxation behavior over long time periods from short-duration measurements at elevated temperatures.

Isothermal Hold Tests

Bonded assembly specimens held at service temperature for extended periods (weeks to months), with periodic dimensional measurements or stress measurements, directly characterize the relaxation behavior under conditions relevant to the actual application.

Managing Thermal Relaxation in Bonded Assembly Design

Cure at service temperature or above: Allowing relaxation to occur during the cure process, at a temperature equal to or above the maximum service temperature, establishes a stress-free reference state at that temperature. Subsequent service-temperature exposure produces no further relaxation beyond what occurred during cure.

Select adhesives with high relaxation temperature: Adhesives with higher Tg begin to relax at higher temperatures. For applications where elevated service temperatures must not cause relaxation, selecting an adhesive with Tg well above the service temperature maintains the bond in its elastic state.

Account for relaxation in preload calculations: Design sealing and clamping joints with enough initial preload to maintain adequate performance after the expected amount of relaxation over the service life.

Monitor dimensional stability in prototypes: For precision assemblies, measuring drift over time at service temperature on prototype units reveals actual relaxation rates before committing to production design specifications.

Incure’s Relaxation Resistance Approach

Incure characterizes relaxation modulus and creep compliance for high-temperature adhesive products at multiple temperatures, providing the material data needed for service life analysis of stress-sensitive bonded assemblies. High-Tg formulations maintain elastic behavior to higher temperatures, reducing relaxation rates in thermally demanding applications.

Contact Our Team to discuss stress relaxation characterization data and adhesive selection for assemblies requiring long-term dimensional stability or sustained sealing force.

Conclusion

Thermal relaxation in bonded assemblies progressively reduces residual and mechanically induced stresses at elevated temperatures, with consequences including seal preload loss, precision alignment drift, differential warping, and unexpected load redistribution. Managing relaxation requires understanding its temperature and time dependence, designing seals and precision joints with adequate relaxation margin, and selecting adhesives whose Tg keeps them in the elastic regime at service temperature. For assemblies where relaxation is unavoidable, structuring the cure process to allow controlled relaxation before service avoids unplanned drift during operation.

Visit www.incurelab.com for more information.